Customer Reviews
Stark story relates social history - By: Anna Gardiner, 23 Sep 2004 
Sad as it is, I love this film. It reminds me that not everythingin the world is black & white. If you like a film that considers injustice & has a courtroom scene.. or you like films setin 50s/60s Britain.. then this is for you. Based on a true story.
"Let him have it" Film on the true story of Derek Bentley. - By: , 08 May 2004 
"Let him have it" is the true heart breaking story of a 19yr old boy with the mental age of an 11yr old who is hanged for murdering a police officer. When I started watching this film it must have only taken 10 minutes but I was hooked the film cast were amazing & the performance by Christopher Eccleston had mein tears by the way he portrayed Derek Bentleyin such a true to life way it was as if i was watching a video starring Derek Bentley. I dont usually cry at films but it was such an emotional story & tha fact that it was true life made it more emotional by just realising that his poor family had to go through all that.I think the film was totally believable & I could watch it again & again. The Cast & the Crew were incredible well done to everyone. Derek Bentley & his family may not have got justice all those years ago but everyone who was involvedin the project has done him justice nowin helping them clear his name & be pardoned.
THEY LET HIM HAVE IT... - By: Lawyeraau, 03 Jan 2003 This film, based upon a true story, illustrates the misapplication of the death penalty. In 1953 England, a slow-witted young man, Derek Bentley, was executed, hanged for his alleged partin the killing of a police officer. It was a case that received much notoriety at the time.
Derek Bentley (Chris Eccleston) was a learning disabled, young man who was easily led. His sister, Iris (Clare Holman), however, treated him like a regular bloke, & he thrived under her watchful eye. His steadfast, working class parents, William & Lilian Bentley (Tom Courtenay & Eileen Atkins), did everything they could to ensure that their son would stay on the straight & narrow. Still, boys will be boys, & one night, Derek, wanting to be one of the boys, simply hooked up with the wrong crowd who was up to no good. Although Derek was unarmed, another of the other boys was not, & when an inevitable clash with the police came about, a police officer was shot. Derek's by now famous words, "Let him have it", were the catalyst for his trial, conviction, & execution.
Notwithstanding Derek's learning disability, the ambiguity of the statement attributed to him, & his tangential involvement during the shootout with the police, Derek was given the death penalty. The draconian sentence was a heartbreaking blow to Derek & his family, as it was always Derek's position that he meant for the shooter to let the police have the gun. Nearly forty-five years later, after persistent efforts by his beloved sister, Iris, Derek was finally exonerated by the very courts that had earlier found him guilty. In reality, it was too little, too late, for Derek.
Chris Eccleston gives a bravura performance as the slow-witted Derek, compelling & moving. He plays him as a young man who was aware of his shortcomings & very much wanted to be accepted by his peers. Tom Courtenay & Eileen Atkins are outstanding as the loving parents whose steadfast beliefin the system is derailed at the last. Clare Holman is excellent as the sister whose expectations of her brother would never fail to make him try harder. Allin all, the entire cast gives notable performances. Superbly directed by Peter Medak, it is a film well worth watching.
"Let Him Have It" my review By Lisa Cooper - By: , 24 Sep 2002 "Let Him Have It"was a very moving film based on a sad but true real life story.It really changed my view on capital punishment. Sadly Bently was at the wrong place,at the wrong time,and also said the wrong words to,"Let Him Have It!".At first i thought Bently meant shoot,but then as the film went on,i realised he meant give him the gun.
The film showed the story to it's best,i think this because the court case scene was brilliant.The acting was at a high level & also the script was well written.
By watching the film it made us feel sorry for Bentley, but to me i also felt abit sorry for Craig,because he was just trying to live the life of a ganster from the movies & make something out of life,apart from living with rashons &in povity.This didn't help under the inflowance of his older brother,who was given 12years inprisonment just before Bently & Craig decided to break into the warehouse.
I think this film is well worth watching & people who agree with capital punishment should see this,because they would proberly change their minds.This film shows the capital punishment systemin those days to its best.
Thought-provoking issue film about capital punishment - By: , 12 Mar 2002 In 1991 Peter Medak directed this film, which is based on the true story of Derek Bentley, a 19 year-old simple-minded youth, who was hangedin 1953 for the murder of PC Sidney Miles when he & his friend, Christopher Craig, had been caught by the police trying to rob a Croydon warehouse.
The story centres around the life of Derek, a teenager whose brain was seriously damagedin a bomb attack on London during the second world war. With a mental age of 11, he knows Christopher, aged 16 who us obsessed with American gangster movies & follows the example of his older criminal brother. After committing a couple of thefts they end up cornered by the police on the roof of a warehouse they are trying to rob. When Derek is arrested, he shouts "Let him have it" & then Christopher starts to live his gangster dream by shouting everywhere, killing a policeman & jumping off the roof to avoid being caught.
Although it is a true story, we have to admit that is also very convincing due to the outstanding performance of the star & to a really well written script, which makes the film very moving & sometimes shocking as well.
"Let him have it" is not only a drama but it is also a thought-provoking issue film about capital punishment & the British justice system. This film claims justice is not perfect, it does make mistakes & everybody who believesin death penalty should see it so they can have second thoughts about killing a man, perhaps an innocent man.
Omar T.
